Nothing enhances the appearance of a nicely executed maneuver more than billowing clouds of white smoke following the aircraft. This is true of full scale as well as our model aircraft. Even so - so maneuvers look more attractive with smoke. Have you ever seen a plane do a really good stall turn with smoke? When done correctly, the plane will almost disappear in a cloud of smoke - most impressive!
It's not really very difficult to set up our model airplanes with a good effective smoke system if we follow some basic guidelines. Follow along with me and I'll attempt to describe some of the things I've learned either through first hand knowledge or from what others have written.
Every activity or task is easier when it is broken down into elements. So it is with smoke systems. These elements are 1, A heat source; 2, Smoke fluid; 3, Fluid delivery systems; and 4, Control systems. The following is a closer look at each of these elements:
1) The Heat Source The heat producer that we have readily available to us is the internal combustion engine that powers our model. With some exceptions, we use three different types of engines: gasoline fueled two-stroke, glow fueled four-stroke and glow fueled two stroke engines. I've listed these in the order of being most effective smoke producers to less effective.
The reason that the gasoline two-stroke engine is the best for producing smoke is that the exhaust is the hottest of the three types listed while the exhaust from a glow fueled two-stroke is relatively cool by comparison. This is important because it is the exhaust gas that creates the heat that in turn produces smoke.
To overcome the relatively cool temperature of the two-stroke glow engine, a smoke fluid pre-heater is very desirable. This can be as simple as a coil of brass or aluminum tubing wrapped around the muffler. A more effective pre-heater is a coil inside the muffler. The idea is to warm the smoke fluid before spraying it into the path of the exhaust inside the muffler. One approach I've seen but don't recommend is a coil around the cylinder head. This could cause the engine to overheat. While a pre-heater is not essential for a gas engine, it can be helpful. I don't use one on my Chipmunk but I will on my Waco. Very good after-market smoke mufflers are available. Two vendors I can think of are B & B Specialties and Slim Line.
2) Smoke Fluid Good commercial smoke fluids are available and carried by our local hobby shops. I've used the Super Dri brand with good results. For you more adventurous types, there are several formulas for home brews. These include: - #2 diesel oil
- Kerosene
- 50 - 50 diesel & kerosene
- Diesel & automatic transmission fluid
- Diesel & concrete form release oil
I haven't tried any of these.
3) Fluid delivery systems I'm aware of four different means of getting the smoke fluid from the tank to the muffler. They are: - Engine pressure driven diaphragm pump
- Electric pump
- Oscillating pump
- Pressurized fluid tanks
There are pros & cons for each. The Diaphragm Pump This pump is driven by engine crankcase pressure. These are generally used with gas engines and are not suitable for four-stroke or small glow two-stroke engines. The engine is fitted with a crankcase pressure tap and a pressure line hooks to the pump. The pump draws the fluid from the tank and delivers it to the muffler. It doesn't pressurize the tank - a big advantage!
The Electric Pump These are as the name implies a small pump driven by an electric motor. These pumps can be used with all types of engines. I've just purchased the "Simple Smoke Pump" for my Waco from Tejera Microsystems and it looks like a wellengineered unit with a good reputation. The disadvantage of electric pumps is that they require a separate battery pack. Also, you must insure by means of a good radio range test that the electric motor isn't sending out spurious signals that can cause glitching. But you routinely range check anyway don't you. As with the diaphragm pump, electric pumps draw the smoke fluid from the tank.
The Oscillating Pump This style pump has an oscillating piston that is driven by engine vibration. These are particularly useful with four-stroke engines. One disadvantage is that they don't deliver the volume of the other two types of pumps. Like the others though, they draw the fluid from the tank. Connelly Mfg. (formerly Perry Mfg.) offers a pump of this type.
Pressurized Fluid Tanks This system relies on engine pressure to pressurize the fluid tank to deliver the smoke fluid to the muffler. This is usually achieved with a pressure tap on the engine crankcase or muffler pressure with a one-way valve. The advantage of this method is that it is very light but a major drawback is that the pressurized tank inevitably will spring a leak and soak the inside of the airframe. Believe me, you don't want this to happen! For this reason, I don't recommend this method.
5) Control Systems Small engine smoke systems will use 2 to 3 ounces of fluid per minute whereas some of the larger gas engine set-ups will use 4 or more ounces per minute. For this reason as well as esthetics, we want to emit smoke only during maneuvers. Therefore we need a means to turn the flow of smoke fluid on and off at will. The system used will determine the items needed to accomplish this.
A servo actuated control valve is used with the diaphragm pump, oscillating pump and the pressurized tank. The servo plugs into either the retract channel or an auxiliary channel of your receiver. This is a simple piston type on-off valve. The one I'm using was supplied by B & B Specialties.
The electric "Simple Smoke Pump" plugs directly into the receiver and has an electronic switch that controls the pump. A second connector hooks up to a battery pack. Usually, 500 mah is sufficient. Either the retract or an auxiliary channel works well.
Another item that is required is a flow control valve. This valve controls the amount of fluid going to the muffler. Too little fluid results in thin, wispy smoke. Too much fluid can cause the same problem in addition to the problem of wasted fluid that accumulates on the airplane exterior. This can be a simple clamp type valve that remains hidden away in the innards of the airframe or it can be a needle valve that can be adjusted from the outside of the model. Originally, the valve on my Chipmunk was accessible only when the wing was off. This certainly does not facilitate fine tuning the flow rate. I've since changed the set-up so it can be adjusted while the engine is running.
Finally, a one way check valve is required. Consider that the pump is trying to pump fluid in to a muffler that is, in effect, pressurized. This pressure will try to push the fluid back into the tank. Both the diaphragm and oscillating pump have pressure pulses. It's between these pulses that the muffler pressure can reverse or retard the flow of fluid. For quite some time, I was getting excellent smoke from my Chipmunk. But recently, the smoke was thin at full throttle. I didn't think that I changed anything and was puzzled as to the cause of the problem. Finally, it dawned on me that I had made a change. I was having a problem with the muffler bolts becoming quite loose. This problem was solved only recently, with much help from Richard Majors. I wasn't using a check valve and when the muffler bolts were loose, the muffler pressure was reduced. Now that they remain tight, the pressure is higher. I've since installed a check valve and it appears that the problem has been eliminated. When an electric pump is off, the muffler pressure can reverse the fluid flow in the pump - even to the point that the pump can lose its prime.
Finally, I've tried to cover the high lights and provide the information needed but space and limited knowledge prevents me from getting into further detail. For more information, I highly recommend a pamphlet published by Tejera Microsystems Engineering titled "Secret Smoke Success Tips". Also, I'll try to answer any questions that you come up with. Good luck! |